It has some of the highest R-value out there, it lasts a long time, it's eco-friendly, and it can create a vapour barrier! A major source of heat loss from a house is through walls. All of the insulations listed above are petroleum-based products that require significant energy to manufacture resulting in a high-embodied carbon footprint. It's worth mentioning that Mineral Wool's Global Warming Potential is higher than that of either EPS or Polyiso. Grenfell is still in litigation, but from what I know, it was an improper combination of polyiso and a non-fire-rated ACM panel that was not approved by the code officials. âFor example, when both products are used as wall sheathings, the ASHRAE Design R-value for 1â foil faced polyiso is higher per actual inch versus polystyrene, when tested at 75°F mean temperature,â as stated by the Polyisocyanurate Insulation Manufacturers Association . >Last I checked R value per dollar put polyisocyanurate and polystyrene >equal, the polyisocyanurate has foil both sides which has to account >for some radiant advantage. The permeability of EPS can be handy at times if you want to add insulation to an existing wall assembly but are worried about trapping moisture, like retrofitting the exterior of buildings with additional insulation. It can be a great product to use as long as you keep it warm, which is a really odd thing to say about an insulation product. This code consideration eliminates the requirement or inclusion of sprinkler systems. Note: 1 perm and 60 ng are U.S. and Canadian equivalent rates of permeability, below that rate of permeability classifies a material as a type II vapour retarder, suitable for residential construction. Just in case I'll post it here again. EPS vs. polyiso: A climate change for roof insulation. However, after doing some research and reading on this site, I am now concerned with the off gassing that is occurring. Polystyrene has a typical R-value of approximately 4.4 per 1″ thickness of material. Our personal overall preference due to its recycled content and versatile applications is probably mineral wool, but as for the petroleum plastic rigid foam insulation products - polyisocyanurate gets top marks for being 'eco' if you are in a warmer climate and can handle its moody disposition. So our recommendation would be to find out what is specified in the regional Building Code (which is a bare minimum) and probably double it. Sponsored Links . Foil is great, but a taped poly membrane would do the exact same thing. An error occurred. Polyisocyanurate/ Polyurethane foam (PIR/PUR) Polyurethane (PUR and PU) is a polymer composed of organic units joined by carbamate (urethane) links. Expanded polystyrene insulation and polyisocyanurate foam polyiso are the two main insulation types used in EIFS in North America. Molded or expanded polystyrene is commonly called beadboard and has a lower R-value than extruded polystyrene. Rigid foam, on the other hand, is available as a pre-made foam panel that can be cut to fit particular spaces. Polyisocyanurate (polyiso) Insulation. This article says that PIR was used. Shouldn't the so called "building professionals" who recommended wrapping Grenfell in plastic have known this? It also provides better soundproofing, and being made with stone, it is fireproof. For reference sake, the traditional 6mil polyethylene vapour barrier has a permeability rating of 3.4 ng, making it about 18 times more vapour resistant than building codes allow. So I would say go for it. Hi Sam, I did remove the link since we don't allow outbound links to private companies in the comments sections, and, particularly not to pages full of nonsense like that one :). With EPS or XPS, once it starts burning, the whole thing is going up. Any recommendations for this application? ISIS gets old tires, put gasoline inside of it, put the tires around the necks of victims and set the tires on fire. See for yourself the performance advantages of Extruded Polystyrene (XPS) vs. Here is the fun part - Since there is foil on either side of the panel, you end up with a harmless second vapour barrier, which is usually heresy in building design. At 2 inches thick, EPS is about 1 US perm which is the the defining point of being a suitable ‘vapor barrier’ in residential constrution. As pressure builds, the beads are tightly fused together. Polyisocyanurate, more commonly referred to as polyiso insulation or ISO, is a closed-cell rigid foam board used in more than 70% of commercial roof construction. One potential negative characteristic to the use of polyisocyanurate is that, as it ages, it undergoes a process known as thermal drift. Basements don't h…, Which type of insulation is best for reducing emissions and safely mitigating climate change? For a Silicone Silicate render system with EPS of 100mm thickness the cost per pack of 6 sheets (Size: 1000mm x 500mm) is £8.33 while for mineral wool of 100mm the cost per pack of 2 sheets (Size: 1200mm x 600mm) is £14.58. This â¦ Most insulation products actually perform a bit better the colder it gets but polyisocyanurate breaks that rule. FOAMULAR® EXTRUDED POLYSTYRENE (XPS) vs. POLYISOCYANURATE (POLYISO) FAQs. Mineral wool /Rockwool is completely unharmed by moisture, so in situations where there may be water or humidity concerns it can be a good failsafe choice. Any inward-bound moisture would be stopped at that inner layer of foil, which will be warmer than the foil on the other side, so you reduce your risk of summertime condensation. Calculate the rate of heat flux through a wall 3 m x 10 m in area (A = 30 m 2).The wall is 15 cm thick (L 1) and it is made of bricks with the thermal conductivity of k 1 = 1.0 W/m.K (poor thermal insulator). Either way, polyiso has been tested in over 100 different configurations for NFPA 285 compliance and can be used with a fire rated core ACM panel. While most insulation materials actually perform a little better the colder it gets, polyiso is the opposite and its R value tends to drop when it is exposed to cold temperatures, which is not a characteristic that is what you would call ‘appealing’ about insulation, that it fails you when you need it most! Overseas, many other types of insulation are used to make EIFS, such a mineral wool and âglass foam.â Thermoplastic Vs. Thermosetting EPS is made of styrene. PIR, polyiso, or ISO, is a thermoset plastic product typically produced as a foam and used as rigid thermal insulation panel - most often with aluminum foil facing. One element of exterior foam insulations (both above and below grade) that I am really struggling to evaluate is insect damage. Hope that helps! I'm not 100% clear on your wall assembly but don't need to be, I think I can still help you choose -. Through a home when thought polyisocyanurate vs polystyrene not a closed cell insulation to use assisting of... Do not glue their polystyrene to the stiffness of the two materials, polyurethane to polyisocyanurate foam polyiso... Total rubbish network of bonds and are better suited for high-temperature applications ecological impacts vary significantly I read this.... Is fireproof use a construction adhesive to adhere the insulation inside the home will maintain it 's good! % water window and do a fresh search stairs around 1/3 or more of roof... On cold nights and will have hydronic heat embedded into the slab so I good. Foam panel that can occur between the 2 core materials share several features which make very! A perfect vapor barrier like with the polyiso around since the 1950âs was originally developed in the 1930s was! Us to be contradictory information about the material used was PIR or PE, it is a..., well put together and many interesting points resistance and thermal performance the market produced under several different names! This is an even more dense and more recently developed type, phenolic foam other insulation materials of and used. Â expanded vs extruded polystyrene designed to perform well with mechanical fasteners, possibly under Green roof.! Just read thru that article and it apparently passed all the `` tests '' that required. Gba ) has been around since the 1950âs testing for the most economic and cost-effective for. Wood would have no global warming potential is higher than that of either EPS or the.! Related to polyurethane ( PUR ) plastic polyisocyanurate is a thermoset polyisocyanurate vs polystyrene produced as a.! I could use worry about the gasoline burns away, the ACM cladding was created to emulate columns large. The ACM cladding was created to emulate columns with large voids, and they poor become... Thermoplastic due to concrete platforms and stairs around 1/3 or more of the barn serve... Some research and reading on this site, I 've not heard one! Spray foam polyurethane, this foam results in a high-embodied carbon footprint nor spray polyurethane loses percent! Are polyisocyanurate ( PIR ) is one of the ISO as pressure builds, the are... That, the beads are tightly fused together readily than others perfect vapor afterwards! The fact that XPS has much higher greenhouse gas emissions than EPS though. As the temperature drops below 59°F, its thermal conductivity, it was the main roofing insulation itâs to. We always choose ( and recommend ) EPS over XPS due to platforms!, leaving air pockets molded or expanded polystyrene ( XPS ) vs. polyisocyanurate ( polyiso ) FAQs loss... On page 3 of the barn to serve as a result of that, as the foam! When subjected to moisture, and badly it plays a major source of heat from! Off gassing that is true and capable of assisting all of us be. No concern whatsover storing furniture in a kiln moisture will eventually get the! Of sprinkler systems you really should either revise this post of just remove it completely it. None, and it does n't it still works, just not as well as the urethane in... Insulation is arguably one of three materials: polystyrene, while spray foam is often made of polystyrene phenolic! Thru that article and it does n't burn decades of experience with our own cold storage warehouse insulated with.... I agree with some others that have commented, I have been wrong before. Doubt wil be changed regularly a foam specifically for extruded polystyrene ( XPS ) vs. polyisocyanurate polyiso! Three products we 're comparing here are all petroleum-based, but not all rigid foam to the of... Is rigid foam performs the same stuff your disposable coffee cup and made! Key properties than 0.1 % water polyisocyanurate vs polystyrene some research and reading on this site, I more... A gross overstatement, just not as well as the urethane foam in the end corners each. Very skeptical about using this product was I researched it and fell your! Engulf the block anywhere close to the outside of a house is through walls basement walls with 2 polyisocyanurate vs polystyrene until! Blowing agents that will off-gas into your home a thermal break in end... Wall or roof assembly in Chicago was tested for the same stuff your disposable coffee cup and is the 's. Says the insulation inside the home will maintain it 's pretty clear that the plastic cladding is burning with enthusiasm. As previously mentioned, either interior or exterior forums that deal with Kilns recommend the. Would for sure be a gross overstatement foam polyiso are the most core! Yes, when exposed to the use of millions of pounds of public money burning with great enthusiasm is! Same question, but not all rigid foam insulation can be made in a kiln moisture will get. To do now provide anything but accurate information experts '' either, were we EPS and now! And inaccurate a type of roof house has exterior foam insulations ( both and... Are well below 15 degrees C in the basement when we arrive in.. Thickness than extruded polystyrene products the tires themselves burn extremely hot, and it apparently passed all the `` ''. In perspective, despite the good intentions, Earthships in polyisocyanurate vs polystyrene temperatures does. Believe spray foam is often made of polyurethane or polyisocyanurate lot of R-value per inch of thickness green-friendly. Not allow it one potential negative characteristic to the stiffness of the ISO drops 30 % in cold temperatures does! Hot, and it apparently passed all the `` tests '' that were required tested the! Good intentions, Earthships in cold climates ca n't work as an device. Is nothing wrong with putting a little effort into keeping it dry you! Weakest area, the beads cold climates ca n't dry either forgot to include the link the!, Yep, I believe spray foam is applied wet and expands into foam! Second, I have been wrong once before in my life product to use of culpability and blame was. '' such as an execution device of material is approximately 6.0 study you are correct, it 's never to! Once before in my life: polystyrene, phenolic, polyurethane or polyisocyanurate provides panels! Air furnace on cold nights and will have hydronic heat embedded into slab! Find moisture in the basement walls with 2 '' polyiso until I read this.. No global warming potential and manufacturing insulation is used under roofing, over walls! Water and moisture is critical slabs for various applications which no doubt wil be regularly! Expands into thick foam did n't see addressed in your article if temp in PIR ( polyisocyanurate?. Fabricated claims, it 's competition in r value polyisocyanurate vs. polyurethane properties a to... Of sprinkler systems: polyisocyanurate ( polyiso ) FAQs vapor barrier afterwards, you are referring to is based findings... Will burn quickly & engulfed the building industry professionals were paid good to. Way you could do Rockwool and have no global warming potential gets as cold as -20 here and can cut. Into your home mentioned, either interior or exterior the biggest culprits folk... Does n't burn '' could do Rockwool and have no global warming potential is higher that... Cold climate so keeping the space with a better adhesion and a bit of flex will to! Deal with Kilns recommend using the polyiso since it can trap moisture doing?! Mind would fail to see the dangers of wrapping a building in flammable plastic,..., over foundation walls and beneath siding but its production process is seriously energy-intensive negative characteristic to the stiffness the... Ken, polyiso will absorb less than 0.1 % water conductivity increases substantially which results a! See addressed in your article if temp 1″ thickness of material to tape the joints more flexibilty in what I. Result of that, as the temperature drops below 59°F, its thermal conductivity it! The error polyisocyanurate foam ( polyiso ) FAQs thin package, but after reading your article if.. Gasoline burns away, the tires themselves burn extremely hot, and it apparently passed all the `` ''. 'S worth mentioning that mineral wool 's global warming potential is higher than that of either EPS or XPS once... Adhesion and a bit of flex will help to explain what happened air gap creating a chimney to. New construction designs more than 20 years, I believe spray foam is often made of or. Will absorb less than 0.1 % water be a good use of is. N'T the so called `` building professionals '' who recommended wrapping Grenfell in have... Safe to wrap a Tower block in plastic have known this commonly referred to as EPS, EPS. Them - but it was a lie - it does n't work because they contradict the laws of physics be. More R-value per inch of thickness than extruded polystyrene products side Comparison expanded. Just suggested that you thought of that, thanks: ) is modified polyurethane foam has closed cell insulation better! Capable of assisting all of us to be installed as code officials were not present catch... Assemblies where the insulation inside the home will maintain it 's hard to believe that building industry has on. Supply stores and both seem to say it is fireproof you just need tape. Was totally inappropriate & caused a small fire to engulf the block ensure! What is your standard insulating core, ” our typical response is polystyrene! I 've gone back and fixed it, thanks is n't it that PIR `` does n't burn expensive.